Former BJP MP Pratap Simha has ignited a wave of controversy with incendiary remarks calling for the closure of mosques and madrasas in Karnataka, drawing sharp condemnation from opposition parties and civil society groups. His comments, made during a public address and widely circulated on social media, come amid rising communal tensions in districts like Maddur and Mysuru.
The Provocation: A Call for Hardline Leadership
Simha, known for his polarizing rhetoric, declared that Karnataka needs a leader with the “guts” of Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Yogi Adityanath — someone who, in his words, would “close down mosques and madrasas that are a threat to social harmony.” He accused the Congress-led state government of “appeasement politics” and suggested that only a Hindutva-driven administration could restore order and cultural pride.
“We need a Yogi Adityanath-like leader who is committed to his dharma,” Simha said, without citing specific incidents or evidence to support his claims.
Political Fallout and Communal Context
The remarks have triggered a political storm, with Congress leaders calling them “irresponsible and dangerous.” The party accused the BJP of attempting to import Uttar Pradesh’s brand of divisive politics into Karnataka, where recent communal clashes have already strained public trust.
“Instead of promoting development and peace, the BJP is trying to polarize the electorate,” said a Congress spokesperson, demanding disciplinary action from the BJP’s national leadership.
Simha’s comments come on the heels of violence in Maddur, where a Ganesh procession was attacked, and tensions in Mysuru, where he previously threatened to demolish bus shelters he claimed resembled mosques.
History of Controversy
Simha, a former two-term MP from Mysuru-Kodagu, has a history of provocative statements. He was recently embroiled in a row over Parliament security after visitor passes issued under his name were misused during a breach. His repeated invocation of Yogi Adityanath — who himself has made controversial remarks about mosque structures — signals a push for a more aggressive Hindutva narrative in Karnataka.
Civic Response and Legal Implications
Human rights advocates and religious leaders have condemned Simha’s remarks, warning that such rhetoric could incite violence and deepen communal divides. Legal experts suggest that calls to close religious institutions without due process may violate constitutional protections under Articles 25 and 26, which guarantee freedom of religion and the right to manage religious affairs.
BJP’s Silence and Strategic Calculus
As of Monday evening, the BJP’s central leadership has not issued a formal response. Analysts believe the party may be weighing the electoral impact of Simha’s remarks, especially in light of upcoming municipal elections and the broader national climate of religious polarization.
